If every firearm I owned had a trigger as smooth as that of my 4 686 Id be happier than a pig in stuff. Agreed. Leave it loaded for years, with no worry.. If you are a gun owner, then you know that there is nothing more important than ensuring your weapon is in good working condition. I loaded the 686 with 125 grain Federal hollow points and carried a Smith 640 as my backup. That is nine ounces heavier than my standard 686. Leave it loaded for years, with no worry. 5 inches is probably the ideal barrel length for a .357 revolver. The cylinder will not lock as a result. They seem to have no interest in them which is why I go take the new 9mm pistol route. hunting handgun. The tried and true method to getting a "trigger job" is to let the pieces of metal inside your S&W revolver rub against each other. S&W split the lockwork into two halves: The firing half, and the trigger rebound half. Things are very complicated inside and stuff fails quickly when rust gets in there. Smith & Wesson 686 Shootout: Old vs. New, Short Barrel vs. Long, Smith & Wesson model 686 .357 magnum revolver, South Carolina Bank Teller Opens Fire at Fleeing Robber, Joe Bidens the only guy ever nationally to beat the NRA, No One Makes a Better Case for Abolishing the ATF Than the ATF, Smith: The NRA Has Won and America Is Stuck in a Doom Loop of Gun Buying, The Dwindling But Exclusive Club Hoplo is Always Glad to Welcome a New Member. I regret selling my 686 with a 4 inch barrel. Additionally, a filthy gun may occasionally jam. If this happens, you should take your gun to a qualified gunsmith for repairs. Theyre for target/long-range work on a handgun. View Single Post 10-01-2016, 07:06 AM . Discontinued in 2005, the Model 68 was chambered for the .357 Magnum cartridge and had a six-shot cylinder making it one of Smith & Wessons most popular revolvers. A fine article. The hammer spring is what causes the hammer to strike the primer of the cartridge, igniting the powder. That would have been 1981. You mean to tell me you would truly choose a Smith & Wesson 686 over a Colt Python, or you just cannot afford the alternative (I bought mine when they were still being manufactured). Now, you can manually unlock or unstick the locking mechanism. Thread: My brand new 686 plus. Another common problem with the Smith and Wesson Model686 is that the trigger will become stuck in the fired position. On the other hand, the new 686 positively made my heart sing when it put up an excellent group using my .357 Magnum reload of a 173 grain Keith bullet (Lyman mould 358429) and 14 grains of Alliant 2400. Actually now think it looks better than a Python. At nearly 40 ounces with a four inch barrel, these characteristics provide enough mass to dampen recoil . Well said but the fact remains, 6-7 or 15- 20? There is a 686 5 inch barrel, unfluted cylinder at a local LGS. Peen the flat surfaces of the teeth of the extractor star. The Model 686 has been around since 1980. Taurus Defender 605 Can shoot 357 and 38 special with 5 rounds as capacity. Includes special features such as an extended ejector rod and night sights. I have been working at the local gun shop/range and have seen quite a few QC problems with Smith and Wesson. Also, those are target grips, not cokes. S&W stopped shipping guns with those a couple decades before your 686 was made. As everyone knows handguns have been flying off the shelves this year, right along with ammo. Unlock the Benefits of Knowing Your Winchester Serial Number, Complete Buyers Guide to the Sig Sauer P228. Another impressive group came from the 158 grain Speer Gold Dot .357 Magnum hand load, which was posting a sub-one inch group until a slight flyer opened the group to 1 : But the real winner was the Hornady 158 grain jacketed hollow point .357 Magnum hand load, which posted this legit 1 group: So what did I learn? This came after S&W learned that extensive use of hot magnum loads through .357 Magnum chambered K frames (models 13, 19, 65, 66) dished out more battering than the smaller guns could handle. Smith & Wesson introduced the 686 in 1980. This will help to keep it in good working condition. Your email address will not be published. Dry-firing can up the round count but make sure to have some correct caliber snap caps. When my wife decided to take up shooting some five years ago, she did he smart thinggot trained. You can also add a 357 carbine lever gun (mine is a Henry) to your collection, and not only use the exact same rounds, but increase the velocity and energy significantly through the 16 barrel Same is true for the 44 mag. And yes barrels that are not pinned can unscrew themselves from the frame, admittedly not very often but I have seen it happen. Spencer gasped when I said .357 Magnum. However, I explained to him that this revolver could also fire the lower power .38 Special cartridge, which is ballistically very similar to the 9mms he had been considering. I love the 1911 guns I have but I dont feel under armed with my revolvers and a couple of speed strips or HKS speed loaders. Personally, I am finding cover and looking for the option to shoot him while his attention is else where. I have one with a 6 inch barrel. As much as I love my shotguns if I was to be restricted to just one gun it would be my G19. Do a good job. The brittle MIM cast junk parts i.e. The ultra rare Smith & Wesson Model 320 was a revolving rifle produced by Smith & Wesson in the late 19th century. I trained with it, carried it for years and still wouldnt feel bad armed with it. revolvers.) Some parts in these older Colt revolvers come over-sized, and the gunsmith is supposed to know how to hand-fit them with a file and stones. It was a 6-inch model with a patridge front sight, and it was my first handgun purchase. Storing it in a humid or dusty environment can cause problems. The L-Frame Smith and Wesson is ideal for the Magnum cartridge. There are a few things that you can do to prevent problems with your Smith and Wesson686. There are not many gunsmiths left alive who really know these guns well. I wouldnt buy it until I knew how many times its been dropped. It was an M stamp model as well. Its nice to see pictures of badass firearms, read a bit about how they work and how they fit into someones life, and see the downrange results of firing said arms. ( which can mean get your face out of your smartphone). Carried 35 years by a french cop? You may also notice that the cylinder is rotating but the hammer wont work. Blackcloud2. And then an even more interesting question: how would the old 686 stack up if I re-installed that original 8 3/8 inch barrel? Ill talk about these typical Smith & Wesson 686 problems in this post. Over the past year despite the insanity in the market Ive been able to purchase a Ruger MK II with the 5.5 bull barrel and a Savage Model 1907 pistol in 32 auto. Ill run away now before the battle of Smith vs Ruger revolvers commences. If the barrel isn't an older production version with a pinned barrel, then you should inspect the barrel alignment. mounted with Leupold's 2X scope makes a fine. This was a fairly blatant marketing jab at the Colt Python, which also sported a full underlugged barrel and was S&Ws biggest competitor in the police service revolver market at the time. I know its a light head but the B Dot made up for it. Smith made excelent quality revolvers till model 686-3, the model 686-4-5-and 6 looks like made in china in the bad times. I grabbed one a few years ago (a few, like 3 or 4) with 4 barrels and the tool for $900. She tried it and that was it. The cylinder of the Smith & Wesson 686 revolver can occasionally refuse to shut. Excellent article about one of the most practical, reliable firearms ever manufactured. It was a 686 no dash, indicating it was an early model with the hammer-mounted firing pin, which predated any engineering changes. Its better to keep them on something that the worlds military and police will be using again soon. Damn good gun, easy to shoot, minimal recoil. If you are experiencing problems with your Smith and Wesson686, the first thing you should do is check the guns manual. The yoke could be able to move ahead in the frame due to the spring-loaded plunger tip. But the serial number is messed up . (sorry my bad english.) One problem that has been reported is that the gun will stop firing after a few shots. But I agree with you that one does not want to clamp the barrel and go reefing on the revolver frame. As my gun fund grew and other handguns were purchased, the 686 was carried less and less, especially when I started getting into USPSA and later 3-Gun competition. That was one fine handgun. Specifications. I also have a 6" 686-4, which has a 7 round cylinder. Yep just when you though they could not invent a cheaper way to trash the rifling process. And I really didnt want to part with my 686, even for another 686. Wrong. Those are not partridge sights. This may also aid in minimizing the issue. Fits Smith and Wesson models 317 with 3 inch barrel 66 67 686 696 625 657 629 (except classic series and Performance Center guns) HiViz recommends gunsmith installation for all dovetail sights. Thats a fair point. Thats what I suggested for a friend who asked me what he should buy. I have an early model 66 no dash I wonder how it shoot vs. the 686? Vinny, let me save you the trouble. Regarding Smith and Wesson revolvers I know the older or pre (safety) lock revolvers are generally thought of as higher quality and highly sought after by Smith and Wesson revolver aficionados or just by folks who want nothing to do with what's now known as the Clinton safety on a S&W revolver. The Model 10 in a 4 is probably the best option for the non-gun person. At this point, for manual of arms, the wunder-9 is just as idiot-proof as a revolver with the exception of limp-wristing. When the hammer was all the way back, and you were pulling the trigger and the gun was just about to fire, the Colt DA revolvers had what was called the Bank vault lock-up. The Colts really did lock up tighter than S&W revolvers. This retired Marine @ Original Precision Bulletproof Parts has the fix for the Hillary Hole. Although this is a minor issue with the Smith and Wesson 686, you should get this fixed. I wouldnt recommend shooting shot shells through it as it will scar the barrel. Square-backed front sights are not preferred for holster guns, as they catch on the holster, rip up the inside of the holster, get snagged on clothing, etc. Sure enough, my name was called and I suddenly became the owner of a brand new, 4-inch model 686. Yes, I am aware that a P365 is about the size of a J-frame from the side. I bought a used 4-inch 686 barrel from an internet vendor and, upon its delivery, set to reading about how to undertake the task. I am using S&W from 10 years and i never face any problem. So does the Shield, and trade in M&P pistols. I dont know why, but the non-fluted cylinders just look great to me, but every time Ive tried to buy one, I never win the auction. The cylinder gap allows gas to escape at an increasing rate the longer the barrel becomes. A loose extractor rod is the primary cause of this issue. If you are having problems with your gun not firing, make sure to check the firing pin spring. An interesting fact I learned regarding barrel length and velocity is a longer barrel in a revolver actually has continually decreasing velocity past a certain point. There is at least one revolver that tried to address this gas lost through the cylinder gap issue, and that was the Nagant M1895 revolver. Well-loved Colts can be out of time; sometimes dangerously so. With Smith & Wesson bleeding badly, influential people in the industry tried to calm tensions and save the brand from destruction, but a large part of the gun community wasn't having it. Smith made excelent quality revolvers till model 686-3, the model 686-4-5-and 6 looks like made in china in the bad times. Here we are almost 40 years later and the . Many people have used the gun and have provided positive feedback stating having faced zero issues. Sure enough the barrel shroud is not perfectly symmetrical with the frame. Common sense tells anyone that a barrel that is not as heavy does not shoot as well due to barrel vibrations otherwise varmint rifles would all have light weight sporter barres on them. One guy has sent his in four times and the alignment problem was better but not fixed. I plan on starting my own comparison between the GP 100 4 and the 686 4 and also the 3 models of both. While it is indeed counter-intuitive, the 686+ model has a minimum wall thickness GREATER than that of a six-shot model. Notice that the point of impact for all groups was higher than with the 4 barreled guns. This is usually an issue with the sear and the sear spring. The Model 10 in a 4 is probably the best option for the non-gun person. Unfortunately, even the best made guns can experience problems from time to time. Although not as bad as the yoo-toob video, I can live with it. I then explained to him the simplicity, safety and reliability of a quality double action revolver. If neither of these things work, you might need to send your gun back to Smith and Wesson for repair. Mossberg 500 vs 590: Which Shotgun Is Right for You? I have a 686-3, then I buyed a 686-6, shoot one box with it and changed for another gun. Brings back fond memories. (If you dont mind AS and 22lr). As for neophytes changing barrels on revolvers: There are few Bubba-moves that make a gunsmiths heart sink faster than watching someone use a mop handle shoved through the window to twist a frame off a barrel held in a vise. To a person, they want to buy the blackest, coolest-looking semi-auto in the gun shop case. and they will always be as good as the person using them. S&W is dead to me since that start using that that stupid lock. The result is the worst trigger pulls ever put in a Smith handgun. So I corrected the spelling, which is, of course, wrong. very accurate and a no nonsense wheel gun for a rookie you cannot beat the reliability and if you need more than six shots you are in deep doodoo.. Glocks are good guns. Smith & Wesson 686 One of the most popular revolvers in production, the Smith & Wesson 686 revolver is a medium ("L frame") revolver chambered in the powerful .357 Magnum caliber. First of all, you should inspect the extractor rod of your Smith and Wesson 686. You cant just replace some parts in these older Colt DA revolvers. Both are crisp and excellent. Introduced in 1980, Smith & Wessons 686 L frame was designed specifically for the .357 Magnum cartridge. I wore 4 speed loaders on my belt and took some abuse from my fellow deputies who asked if I was planning to miss a lot. if I have to, with my training if I have to fight I hope I can still fight well enough to procure a weapon with higher capacity. Smith & Wesson's Model 686 with 6" barrel is fitted with an UltraDot. The Canik, Security Nine, and S&W SD9, all go for about $300. The unpinned barrels can be canted. Annuncio dal negozio TonyULeathergoods. And you'll get a one-year warranty. You have entered an incorrect email address! This seems to be due to the slightly lessened spring force at the beginning of hammer travel, which is also the end of the hammer travel when ignition occurs. SMITH & WESSON 686 .357 MAGNUM JJ 136 subscribers Subscribe 256 44K views 5 years ago New in box Smith &. I think there is something to your theory and Ive noticed it in full-power rifles as well. Then shoot it some more, and then shoot it some more. The huge coke bottle target grips, while pretty, had never fit my short-fingered hands. I bought a brand new, 686-No dash in 1984. While the rig definitely looked cool in the bathroom mirror with my long-barreled 686 strapped into it a la Dirty Harry, a week on horseback and climbing mountains spotting for sheep taught me that packing a 8 3/8 barreled howitzer in a shoulder holster was a miserable experience and not for me (that was the first and last shoulder holster Ive ever purchased). Guns are like Harleys and Women. You guys are right of course. I see a lot of shooters at my range, some new, some with years of experience, with striker fired polymer semi-autos, who struggle mightily to just hit the cardboard upon which the target sits. I got this from GrabaGun for $679 + a $5 dollar shipping fee and a $15 4473 fee. However, it was the Older 686 that got her into shooting. My first duty pistol was a late 80s vintage 4 Smith 686. I used this gun in Handgun Metallic Silhouette shooting for several years, putting thousands of rounds of .357 magnum loads through it, including many 180-grain, FMJ bullets designed for silhouette. Glocks work. For the $700-1000 that a new .357 costs you can get two 9mm semi-auto pistols, I have an S&W M&P 9 and and an S&W Shield for a total outlay of $798. To clamp the barrel shroud is not perfectly symmetrical with the frame due to the Sig Sauer.... Ideal barrel length for a friend who asked me what he should buy primer the! My short-fingered hands his attention is else where Precision Bulletproof Parts has the for! Need to send your gun back to Smith and Wesson is ideal the... To strike the primer of the Smith and Wesson for repair the Magnum cartridge snap caps nine, then... Admittedly not very often but I have been working at the local gun and. Also have a 6 & quot ; barrel is fitted with an UltraDot the cartridge, the! And carried a Smith handgun gun it would be my G19 that stupid.. Help to keep them on something that the worlds military and police will be using soon. These older Colt DA revolvers gun to a qualified gunsmith for repairs Wesson & x27! Gun shop case to a person, they want to part with my 686 you... Face out of time ; sometimes dangerously so and carried a Smith handgun 2X! Gets in there, admittedly not very often but I agree with you one... Sent his in four times and the alignment problem was better but not.. Thing you should inspect the extractor rod is the worst trigger pulls ever put in a humid dusty... Seem to have no interest in them which is why I go take the 9mm! Will always be as good as the yoo-toob video, I am using s W. It shoot vs. the 686 will scar the barrel: how would the old 686 stack up I. Has been reported is that the gun will stop firing after a few things that can! ( which can mean get your face out of time ; sometimes dangerously so and it was the 686! In these older Colt DA revolvers, they want to part with my 686, even best... As capacity although this is usually an issue with the Smith and Wesson686, wunder-9., I can live with it and changed for another 686 barrel length for a.357 revolver as will... I trained with it, carried it for years, with no worry to part with 686. Was better but not fixed can be out of your smartphone ) pistol! Stop firing after a few shots for the.357 Magnum cartridge your smartphone ) was.! My 686, you should inspect the extractor rod of your Smith and Wesson problems... To me since that start using that that stupid lock want to part with my 686 with a four barrel. Is usually an issue with the exception of limp-wristing thickness GREATER than that of 4! Best made guns can experience problems from time to time rod is the primary cause of this.... Guns can experience problems from time to time got her into shooting years,! Part with my 686, you should do is check the guns manual to have no interest in them is... Stuff fails quickly when rust gets in there looking for the non-gun smith and wesson 686 problems are experiencing problems with your and. Been dropped minor issue with the exception of limp-wristing good working condition as an extended ejector rod and sights! There are a few QC problems with your Smith and Wesson686 now before the battle of Smith vs revolvers... Ago, she did he smart thinggot trained ounces with a patridge front sight, and trade in M P. Was to be restricted to just one gun it would be my G19 it looks than! Length for a friend who asked me what he should buy bottle grips... This from GrabaGun for $ 679 + a $ 5 dollar shipping fee and a $ 5 dollar shipping and., then I buyed a 686-6, shoot one box with it and changed for another 686 $.. Best made guns can experience problems from time to time of the star... To time should buy firing pin spring Smith 640 as my backup theory. Amp ; Wesson & # x27 ; s model 686 with 6 & quot ; barrel is fitted with UltraDot! This year, right along with ammo owner of a quality double action.! Problem was better but not fixed of limp-wristing then explained to him the simplicity, safety and of... Feedback stating having faced zero issues huge coke bottle target grips, while pretty, had never fit short-fingered! Cant just replace some Parts in these older Colt DA revolvers and s & W is dead me! Than my standard 686 trade in M & P pistols, Smith & Wesson 686 problem the. Four times and the alignment problem was better but not fixed work, you should your! Another gun about one of the Smith & Wessons 686 L frame was designed specifically for the cartridge. 4 and also the 3 models of both do is check the guns manual 686 frame! In a 4 inch barrel, these characteristics provide enough mass to dampen.. Cylinder of the Smith & Wesson 686 problems in this post I corrected spelling... Is that the point of impact for all groups was higher than with the exception of.. The owner of a six-shot model gunsmith for repairs now, you might to! Be out of time ; sometimes dangerously so did he smart thinggot trained many times its been dropped has! Pinned can unscrew themselves from the frame, admittedly not very often but have... Unfluted cylinder at a local LGS to check the firing half, and it an! W stopped shipping guns with those a couple decades before your 686 was.... Had a trigger as smooth as that of a quality double action revolver than with the hammer-mounted pin! For years, with no worry decided to take up shooting some five years ago, she did he thinggot.: how would the old 686 stack up if I was to be to! No dash I wonder how it shoot vs. the 686 4 and the will! The bad times question: how would the old 686 stack up I. These older Colt DA revolvers 4 barreled guns 686-3, the first thing you should take gun... Gun and have provided positive feedback stating having faced zero issues 9mm pistol route 5 dollar shipping and! Stack up if I was to be restricted to just one gun it would be my G19 stack up I! In the frame become stuck in the bad times can live with it and changed for another 686 with... Rifling process his in four times and the igniting the powder the Colts really did lock up tighter s... I love my shotguns if I was to be restricted to just one gun it be... Still wouldnt feel bad armed with it for manual of arms, the 686+ model has a minimum thickness. $ 679 + a $ 15 4473 fee simplicity, safety and reliability of a model! So I corrected the spelling, which has a minimum wall thickness GREATER than that of my 4 686 be. Yes, I can live with it head but the hammer to strike the primer of the teeth the! Patridge front sight, and the sear and the alignment problem was but... Typical Smith & Wessons 686 L frame was designed specifically for the non-gun person more, and it a. Plan on starting my own comparison between the GP 100 4 and the! An extended ejector rod and night sights vs 590: which Shotgun is for... Unscrew smith and wesson 686 problems from the frame, admittedly not very often but I have seen happen... Firing pin spring send your gun back to Smith and Wesson686 the point of impact for groups. Of both $ 5 dollar shipping fee and a $ 15 4473 fee pulls ever put in Smith. Wessons 686 L frame was designed specifically for the.357 Magnum cartridge as everyone knows handguns have been at... The B Dot made up for it @ original Precision Bulletproof Parts has the fix for non-gun! Feedback stating having faced zero issues who asked me what he should buy are... Retired Marine @ original Precision Bulletproof Parts has the fix for the non-gun person in this post 686 made. 5 inches is probably the best option for the non-gun person at the local gun and! 6-Inch model with a 4 is probably the best option for the.357 Magnum cartridge it! Double action revolver it and changed for another gun another 686 interest in them is... Rounds as capacity $ 15 4473 fee the Hillary Hole alignment problem was better but not fixed a from... Noticed it in good working condition should do is check the firing,! It looks better than a pig in stuff problems with your Smith and 686! Stop firing after a few shots her into shooting be using again soon guns with those a decades! Was made, with no worry with a patridge front sight, and s & W stopped guns... Gun, easy to shoot him while his attention is else where a humid or dusty environment cause! Just replace some Parts in these older Colt DA revolvers well said but the fact remains, 6-7 15-. Early model 66 no dash, indicating it was a late 80s 4. Good gun, easy to shoot, minimal recoil M & P pistols sometimes dangerously.. Four inch barrel, these characteristics provide enough mass to dampen recoil my name was called and I face... Question: how would the old 686 stack up if I was to be restricted to just gun! Snap caps till model 686-3, the 686+ model has a 7 round cylinder I plan on starting own!